[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

IPSEC Minutes

Gentlepeople:

I must apologize for the delay in posting these minutes. A copy of these
were sent to Steve Crocker (SAG) and Jim Galvin immediately after the
Ohio meeting. They were previously posted via email but due to a
mailer error (mia culpa) they never reached the IPSEC list. After
this was appropriately pointed out, I attempted to recover/reconstruct
the notes from my crashed AUX system. Its been too long and I apologize
for any/all inconvenience. These are the summary meeting notes. I will
be following with details and posted documents.

Sincerely,

Al Hoover


IP Security Working Group (IPSEC) Meeting 9:30 AM 3-31-93

Chaired by: Al Hoover, ANS CO+RE Systems, Inc. <ahoover@ans.net>
                Paul Lambert, Motorola, Inc. <Paul_Lambert@email.mot.com>

Agenda:

Introduction
        Review and approval of agenda
        Minutes of Washington D.C. posted to ipsec list
        IPSEC Charter has been submitted with final revisions and is being
        shepherded by the Area Director through the approval process.

Review of IPSEC Charter and Task Schedule
        Identification of Working Group Liaisons and Volunteers

        SIP - Ran Atkinson
        AVT - Stuart Stubblebine
        MOBILE IP PIP - John Ioannidis
        CAT - John Linn
        TUBA - Richard Colella
        CIPSO - Ron Sharp
        SC27 - Piers McMahon
        SC6 - Paul Lambert
        IEEE 802.10 Paul Lambert - Russ Housley

Review of Initial Experimental Implementations

John "ji" Ioannidis, Columbia University <ji@cs.columbia.edu >
presented an overview on swIPe.  John will provide a postscript
version of his slides on the archive server.

Jim Zmuda, Hughes Aircraft, Inc  <zmuda@mis.hac.com presented a
presentation entitled "Providing IPSP Services Through NLSP-CL And
A Simple Convergence Protocol.

Paul Lambert, Motorola, Inc. <Paul_Lambert@email.mot.com
presented an overview of Security Protocol 3 (SP3) including
protocol data unit format and modifications for connectionless
support.

Dan Frommer, Digital Equipment Corporation <dan@isv.dec.com>
presented an overview of NetGuard and the Digital Tandu encryption
chip.

Andrew Partan, UUNET Technologies, Inc. presented a brief overview
of the "LAN Guardian" security offering.

Summarize Approach and Recommendations

A preliminary list of IPSEC protocol features/requirements was
discussed and will be posted to the list for further refinement.

Key Management

A brief discussion related to key management took place and it was
suggest that it be continued on the list.

Summary

Next Meeting - An IPSEC meeting will be scheduled for the
Amsterdam meeting.  It was suggested that a VAT conference back
to the states be attempted for Amsterdam.  If there is a requirement
for an interim IPSEC meeting before Amsterdam either a site/date
will be selected or a conference call or VAT will be scheduled.

        Review and closing

Attendees:

Al Hoover               ahoover@ans.net
Paul Lambert            Paul_Lambert@email.mot.com
James Zumda             zumda@mls.hac.com
John Linn               jlinn@mcimail.com
Rob Hagens              hagens@ans.net
Paul Sangster           sangster@ans.net
Philip Lozowick         lozowick@isv.dec.com
Ted Tso                 tytso@mit.edu
Richard Colella         collella@nist.gov
Jeff Schiller           jis@mit.edu
Steve Lunt              lunt@bellcore.com
Rich Graveman           rfg@ctt@bellcore.com
Richard Thomas          rjthomas@bnr.ca
John Campbell           jrcamp@nosc.mil
Jim Weatherford         weatherf@nosc.mil
Rich Bjers              rich.bjers@uc.edu
Jon Fellows             jonf@gdstech.grumman.com
Stefan Fassbender       stf@casi.net
Ran Atkinson            atkinson@itd.nrl.navy.mil
Steve Crocker           crocker@tis.com
Jim Barnes              barnes@xylogics.com
Allyson Showalter       allyson@nsipo.nasa.gov
Cynthia E. Martin       martin@spica.drsa.mil
Joe Pagan               jrp@afterlife.ncsc.mil
Chas DiFatta            cd@sei.cmu.edu
Ron Sharp               rls@neptune.att.com
Radia Perlman           perlman@dsmail.enet.dec.com
Klaus Trugel            trugel@gmd.de
Wolfgang Schneider      wolfgang.schneider@gmd.de
Thyen Vu                vu@polanisi.disa.mil
Rina Nathaniel          rina@md.vndi.uunet.com
Paul Traina             pst@cisco.com
Tom Benkart             teb@saturn.sys.acc.com
Phil Karn               karn@qualcomm.com
Jisso Geiter            geiter@mitre.com
Piers McMahon           p.v.mcmahon@rea0803.wins.icl.co.uk
Dan Hanson              hanson@oas2-tic.af.mil
Antonio Fernandez       afa@thumper.bellcore.com
Charles Perkins         perk@watson.ibm.com
Rich Harris             rharris@atc.boeing.com
Andrew Partan           asp@uunet.uu.net
Barbara Fraser          byf@cert.org
Charlie Kaufman         kaufman@zk3.dec.com
Dan Frommer             dan@jeremy.enet.dec.com
David Conrad            davidc@iij.ad.jp
Kishan L. Dudkikar      kishan@icm1.icp.net
Marcus j. Ranum         mjr@tis.com
John Ionnidis           ji@cs.columbia.edu
Dale S. Johnson         dsj@merit.edu
Steve Kent              kent@bbn.com
Mike St.Johns           stjohns@darpa.mil
Chuck Warlick           warlick@theophilus.msfc.nasa.gov
Rob Shirey              shirey@mitre.org