[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: A pothole in ISAKMP/Oakley



>  Also, it is possible to run a pseudo-random generator once, and use the
>  new random value as SPI for both ESP and AH (since the spec also says
>  they
>  have separate SPI-spaces, see section 2.1 of ISAKMP draft 7). Is this 
>  broken ?
>  I guess it is a border-line case.

The requirement for pseudo-random SPI's was not motivated by key management
concerns, but rather to protect against denial of service attacks, I thought.

> Will it interop, I think so.

I didn't realize that the IETF had strict constructionists!

Hilarie