Re: Moving forward on RFC 2401-bis

["Angelos D. Keromytis" <angelos@cs.columbia.edu>]

Great, we're in agreement.
-Angelos

In message <p05200f01bb6de70acd16@[128.89.89.115]>, Karen Seo writes:
>Angelos,
>
>>Karen, great. One nit: none of the items are "resolved" as such. They need to
>>be discussed on the list first. (That's because, unlike the issues in the IKE
>>draft, these are architectural changes that have not been previously
>>discussed.)
>
>	Sorry for not being clear.  What I was trying to say is
>	that we "believe" they've been resolved (because they've
>	been discussed on the list and a consensus appeared to have
>	been reached) and that we'll circulate descriptions of each
>	issue.  I was assuming that when these were distributed to
>	the list, folks would get a chance to look at the writeups
>	and assess them, presumably with the opportunity to change
>	things etc.
>
>Karen
>
>>Cheers,
>>-Angelos
>>
>>In message <p05200f0dbb6c4b053bc0@[128.89.89.115]>, Karen Seo writes:
>>>Folks,
>>>
>>>Just an update... We've reviewed the 9 items on the IPsec tracking
>>>list for 2401:
>>>
>>>1. We believe the following 5 items have been resolved.  At the
>>>beginning of next week, we will send out individual writeups for the
>>>following items:
>>>	47	All selectors can be a list of ranges, per IKEv2 spec
>>>	48	Add ToS traffic selector option
>>>	49	Red-side fragmentation option
>>>	50	Tunnel vs transport mode
>>>	57	ECN support
>>>
>>>2. Four of the items are inter-related and should be addressed
>>>together as part of the new IPsec processing model, which is still
>>>being discussed.  Later next week, we will send out a revised version
>>>of the write up on the processing model with updates reflecting
>>>feedback/conclusions to date.  This will cover the following items:
>>>	40	Interface SPD selector vs per-interface SPD
>>>	44	Forwarding table lookup to select virtual interface ID
>>>	45	Use of cache with de-correlated SPD
>>>	46	No need for iterated processing
>>>
>>>3. In addition to the items in the tracking system, there are a
>>>number of other issues that have come up during the past months.
>>>Over the next couple of weeks, we will be sending out descriptions of
>>>these issues for group review/discussion.
>>>
>>>Have a good weekend!
>>>Karen
>>>